Sheer Reckoning

What to Expect When Investing in Your Website

For marketing teams and creative leads who know a polished homepage is just the beginning

What to Expect When Investing in Your Website

Your website does a lot more than say “hello.”

It sets the tone for your brand, delivers your message at scale, and…if built right…turns curiosity into action. Whether you're launching something new or trying to fix a site that never quite did the job, investing in your website is one of the most high-leverage moves you can make.

And considering 75% of users judge a business’s credibility based on its website1, that job really matters.

But where do you start? What does it cost? And how do you make sure the result is more than just a digital brochure with your logo slapped on it?

Let’s break it down.

Not All Websites Are Built for the Same Job

First things first: what kind of site are you building? A five-page informational site for a consulting firm is wildly different from an e-commerce storefront or a SaaS platform with user accounts. If you don’t know what you need, your budget and strategy will fall apart fast.

Some common types of websites:

Informational

Think professional services, local businesses, or small teams that need to show up clean and credible.

Brand Storytelling

Heavier on visuals and narrative; great for consumer brands or anyone making an emotional appeal.

Content-Driven

Blogs, resources, videos. Ideal for thought leaders or organizations that win trust through education.

E-commerce

Built to sell, with UX and conversion strategy baked in.

Product/Platform

Marketing sites for apps or software with funnels, feature demos, and lead capture.

Clarifying your site type early is key. It shapes everything from design decisions to platform choice to the amount of content you’ll need.

Where the Money Goes (and Why)

When someone asks, “How much does a website cost?” the honest answer is: it depends. A lot. You’re not just paying for a new coat of paint. A high-performing website requires strategy, collaboration, and technical execution.

Here's what your investment typically covers:

Strategy and UX

Goals, audiences, site architecture. This is your blueprint.

Visual Design

The look, feel, and functionality—customized to your brand.

Content

Copywriting, editing, and making sure your message lands.

Development

Front-end, CMS, integrations. Responsive across devices.

SEO and Performance

Metadata, accessibility, and best practices that help people (and search engines) find you.

Testing and Launch Support

QA, training, documentation, and “what happens after.”

If that sounds like a lot, it is. But skimp on any one part and the whole thing suffers. Cheap sites often come with expensive regrets.

Speaking of Cheap Sites…

There’s a reason we get so many calls that start with: “We had a friend build our site a few years ago and now we’re redoing it.”

DIY sites and budget builds can work…for a minute. But they often come loaded with problems: confusing navigation, clunky CMS setups, poor SEO structure, inconsistent branding, and tech debt that slows you down just as you're trying to scale up.

One study found that 88% of online visitors won’t return after a bad site experience2—so that $2K “deal” might actually be leaking leads every day.

It’s not just about how your site looks. It's how it works.

That doesn’t mean every brand needs a six-figure build. But if your site is critical to how you sell, generate leads, or build credibility? Then cutting corners on the front end will cost you more in the long run.

Timelines Aren’t Set It and Forget It

Custom websites take time. A typical build—from discovery to launch—runs about 8 to 12 weeks (or longer, depending on complexity). That timeline includes:

  • Strategy and goal alignment
  • Sitemap planning and content strategy
  • Wireframes and early design
  • Copywriting and content creation
  • Visual design iterations
  • Development and testing
  • Launch and post-launch support

You’re not just waiting around while this happens. Your team plays a big role: providing assets, giving timely feedback, approving milestones. Delays often stem from content that’s late, stakeholders who go silent, or feedback loops that go off the rails.

How Do You Know If It Worked?

ROI isn’t just a nice-to-have. It’s how you justify the investment. A smart website should lead to real business impact. That might look like:

  • An increase in qualified leads or sales
  • Better SEO rankings and organic traffic
  • Stronger brand credibility
  • Less manual work for your team
  • Faster, easier updates through a CMS that doesn’t make you scream


A well-executed redesign can boost conversions by up to 200%3, and even small improvements, like shaving 0.1 seconds off your load time, have been shown to improve conversion rates by 8–10%.4

Not all of these are immediate. But if your site is working hard behind the scenes—drawing people in, making your brand look sharp, converting interest into action—you’ll feel the difference in your pipeline and your day-to-day.

Choose Your Partner Wisely

You don’t need to go it alone. But you do need the right partner.

A solid web agency won’t just execute…they’ll guide. They’ll ask smart questions, challenge assumptions, and make sure your site aligns with your broader business goals. Look for a team that brings strategy, design, dev, and content under one roof. Because when those pieces work together? That’s when the magic happens.

(And no, your cousin who “knows HTML” probably isn’t the right fit.)

No items found.
Susi Harris
Susi Harris
Founding Partner, Creative Director & Strategist
Susi’s done everything from branding to web design to co-founding a company—and yet still finds time for Doctor Who marathons and annual trips to San Diego Comic-Con. When she’s not busy working on a project, you'll most likely find her curled up with a cat and a good book.

Stay Updated with Our Newsletter

Subscribe to Our Newsletter for Updates and Industry News

Thanks for subscribing!

Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again.

Ready to take your creativity to the next level?

Let’s make something great.
Together.